Transcript 0:00 42375, go ahead. Uh, they said, uh, the roof was for a podcast or something. Is that what we heard? Yeah, that's what I heard. [upbeat music] Good morning, and welcome back to "The VIP Seat." 0:09 We have a very special guest today talking about capital markets and business aviation. Sit back, buckle up, and let's take off. 0:20 [engine roaring] So well, Jesse, we have a super exciting guest today. Uh, this is, this is the M&A gong. For those that don't know, we ring it anytime anybody transacts. 0:35 And, uh, so we have maybe, uh, one of the most influential people in the M&A gong ringing, Nick Fazioli from Jefferies. Nick, thanks for coming on the show. Absolutely. My pleasure. 0:45 It's good to see you guys, and appreciate you, uh, appreciate you having me. Yeah, I think when I first met Nick, uh, someone introduced him to me as, "It's our industry's banker, and you've got to know him." 0:54 So- [laughs]... Nick, I'd love for you to, uh, you know, tell us about your background just for those who don't follow, you know, Wall Street and the investment banking side, uh, so they can understand a little more. 1:03 Yeah. No, no, happy, happy to do it. 1:05 And yeah, I've been extremely fortunate to get to be a very active participant in, in this particular sub-sector of, uh, the broader aviation market, and it kind of happened over, you know, you get involved in one thing, you get involved in the next thing. 1:18 But, um, so yeah, from a, from a title standpoint, I'm, uh, the global head of aerospace and aviation banking, investment banking for Jefferies. 1:26 For those of you who don't know Jefferies, we are, uh, what we like to call a, a pure play, uh, investment bank, uh, on a global level. We're based in New York. I'm based in New York. 1:36 Um, uh, just over 8,000, uh, employees now. Um, uh, but I head our aerospace and aviation vertical in particular, and so that does have a wider, um, you know, sort of addressable market than just business aviation. 1:52 Uh, you know, we advise clients in, uh, commercial aerospace, leasing, uh, the whole MRO and supply chain across, you know, BizAv and, and commercial, and the product base is really everything. 2:05 One of the best things about being at a firm like Jefferies is we're not just a debt specialist or just an M&A shop. We really are kind of full service. So we can do everything from, um, M&A buy side and sell side. 2:16 We can raise capital that is debt, that is equity, public and private, that is hybrid, you know, and if things go, uh, off the rails on the other side, we have a very, uh, uh, strong restructuring practice as well which, which does happen from time to time. 2:31 So, you know, I, I do nothing but this industry and then, you know, sort of at the firm we have product specialists in all the, all the different areas. 2:39 And, um, you know, the business aviation side, and we'll talk about it a little bit, has not really historically been a very large part of, of Wall Street landscape although that's changing rapidly and we've been very fortunate to, um, to be a part a lot of that. 2:54 Uh, but our, our practice 2:56 probably in any given year, I would say over half of what we do is involved in this, uh, this sector, uh, which is, you know, uh, from a share standpoint much higher than I, I think most other firms. 3:08 So I've been at the firm 16 years. 3:11 Uh, prior to that I had a, a career at Delta Airlines, kind of grew up in the commercial world so wasn't really familiar with, uh, the BizAv world until I got to Jefferies and, um, was very fortunate to, um, when I first landed there to, to get synced up with, um, with Kenny Dichter when he was running Marquis Jet right about the time of their, their exit to, um, NetJets and we were fortunate enough to be part of that transaction and, you know, candidly that kind of gave me, uh, gave me my start in this sector and kind of one thing led to another and, you know, it happened to coincide real pickup and investment for, uh, for this, this space. 3:47 So it's, and it's super fun, great people, um, you know very, very interesting, uh, landscape, uh, especially these days. 3:53 So you've, you've, you've seen the, you know, the arc from, you know, no one was in business aviation to now, you know, a lot more people being in it. Yeah, 100, 100%. 4:01 I mean from a Wall Street standpoint most people look at are like people who sit in my seat who are industry specialists. It's usually kind of A and D, right? 4:11 Like aerospace and defense and to some extent aerospace, defense, government. Like those are like the typical kind of, you know, monikers or like the main, the main kind of buckets in. 4:21 You know, aerospace really just historically meant largely commercial. You know, it was basically like the commercial airline supply system and the maintenance system and the manufacturing and all that. 4:32 And you know, maybe you would have your some companies that made things for Gulfstream as they did for Boeing, but it was really a commercial aerospace play and, you know, over in my, I've been at Jefferies now 16 years, that has really kind of come about where all of a sudden BizAv within that kind of aerospace category, you know, really has a, has a life of its own. 4:52 You have some very, very big companies, you know, very large transactions, you know, household name institutional investors and, and even some public market activity in that, that world. 5:02 So, um, you know, once there's a couple good investments in the space and the, the sort of the herd starts to follow along and, and get known it becomes, uh, more of a thing. 5:11 So that's probably been the, yeah, the biggest change in my 16 years is just watching our sector, um, grow up and it, it's been, it's been great to watch because when you're in my seat, right? 5:22 As my wife often tells me, like she's like, "Well, you don't run the companies and you don't actually invest the money into the company." She's kind of like, "What do you, what do you do here?" uh, type of question. 5:31 And you know, at Jefferies we're kind of facilitators, right? 5:33 There's institutional capital and investors that are looking to deploy money to work into the, you know, into the private and public markets, and my job is to go out and bring great companies whether they're public, private, founder-owned, whatever, you know, to them and sort of bring it. 5:47 So for us it's very fulfilling to see, um, you know, this type of activity build up around a sector that was once a little bit of a cottage industry. 5:55 Yeah, I think, I think a good place to start might be kind of piggybacking off that is what is the macro-Attitude towards BizAv right now. 6:04 So it's twenty twenty-- you know, first quarter, end of first quarter of twenty twenty six, uh, there's been, you know, there's a couple of publicly traded companies out there, but just I'd say, like general sentiment towards our section of the industry. 6:16 Yeah. And, and I'll speak broadly, but, but the, the groups that I typically speak for, just to clarify, um, 6:25 you know, and probably the largest and most active group that we deal with would be what I would call the private equity community, whether that's real private equity funds, family offices, there's, you know, there's kind of different variations of it. 6:36 But so let's just say companies that either make-- firms that make investments into companies either for control or for growth. You have your debt investors, right? 6:44 Which are investing in a different side of the, the capital structure, and those can be in just sort of private debt deals or, you know, asset-backed like, like, like you grew up in, um, or publicly syndicated debt. 6:56 And then there's the public markets, um, which are obviously institutional investors, you know, typically investing in, in enlisted companies. 7:03 So there's different variations, um, of sentiment or, um, deal activity across all of them. But I would say we went through... 7:13 So when I started back in-- Just to like step back for a minute, when I started with this at Jefferies in twenty ten, which is about the time of the, you know, the Marquis transaction, you still kinda had a universe from a Wall Street eye. 7:25 Now, keep in mind, these are-- they're very big companies that are out there that just maybe haven't hit, you know, the radar that, that I live in. 7:31 But you kinda had like the NetJets name that was out there under Berkshire. 7:36 You had, you know, sort of Flexes, which were, again, very big companies, but sorta largely privately, closely held, um, you know, and some institutional investment in like the FBO landscape, et cetera. But, um, 7:48 kinda leading up out of, um, really like the oh eight, oh nine financial crisis and like Jet Gate when all the guys went down to Washington in their jets and it caused like this whole, you know, terrible image for, for our industry, um, you know, you started to see a real buildup of, if you just take the charter operator side, like, you know, some big capital and big investment and big growth going into, let's just say, alternatives to whole aircraft ownership, right? 8:15 And you saw that group kinda, uh, build up significantly, and then kind of with it came, you know, a lot of the MRO and FBO activity. So started to get some real momentum. 8:25 Um, you know, there were, at that time, maybe people coming across with like innovative or different ideas or kinda maybe disruptive ways to try to play that space. 8:34 And frankly, the capital markets and institutional investor activity across all these were quite available. 8:39 I mean, we raised a tremendous amount of capital for a lot of your household names, uh, you know, your Vistas, your Flexes, your Wheels Up, um, during that period. 8:48 And then obviously then we kinda led up to COVID, which, um, you know, absent a couple months where we were all scared to death about everything, BizAv kinda took an entire different plane, as we all know, right? 9:01 And commercial kinda went down, um, and we saw a ton of activity. Um, tho-those were actually some of the craziest times, you know, we had during that because, um, 9:11 particularly the strategics were making a lot of, um, investments out of necessity, uh, meaning, you know, people that had sort of guaranteed to their customers that they could provide lift at a certain price and availability, and all of a sudden their universe of sub-charter operators were, you know, either their prices were out of control or there was no availability. 9:30 So there was this mad dash to come back in and acquire lift and pilots and fleet as fast as humanly possible to, to satisfy, you know, their rapidly growing business. 9:39 Um, and then we kinda- Perfect time to sell a charter company. [laughs] Uh, it was a, it was a, it was a very perfect time to sell a charter company, and it was extremely busy times for us doing a lot of that. 9:50 And there were certain people that, you know, just kinda had to have those, those assets and, you know, it worked out. 9:56 Uh, you know, in some cases it worked out well for both sides, and some cases it worked out well for, you know, one side and, and things had to work itself through. [laughs] Um, but 10:06 now we're actually, we're actually in like a really good time now because I think now we're pa-- But then, so the other side of that trade, though, was unfortunately, no one knew what normal was, and that's actually one of the worst things for-from a Wall Street perspective, is when you don't actually know what normal is. 10:21 'Cause you either have buyers and sellers with very different views of valuations because they see things one world. 10:27 Other people are like, "Hey," you know, when you see the big hockey stick earnings and growth, like everyone's like, "Ah, do I really wanna, you know, kinda step into that?" 10:34 So for a period, it actually then became a little difficult, and we had this in like the air cargo space too, right? 10:40 Where everything was getting flown around because the logistics and supply chains were, were kind of a, in, in a mess and, and, you know, all these, you know, kinda air cargo companies had the same thing, was we couldn't find normal, and that's really not good for, for my business. 10:55 Um, so now we've sorta just seen this kinda leveling out, I would say almost like post maybe twenty twenty-two or twenty twenty-three. Like things normalized out, um, 11:07 you know, there wasn't such a frenzy amongst the big, what I call like the branded charter operators. So like, "I gotta have lift, I gotta have this." Like everything kinda got back to normal. 11:15 And I think what comes out of that now is people just say, "Okay, we went from like kind of a cottage industry through some of these companies are really gaining scale, both on the operator side and the supply chain side, to like a crazy burst that then reset." 11:30 But what it reset as was just like a fundamental shift up and then back on a different trajectory, right? 11:36 Because there was a real benefit to COVID in the sense that a lot of people, whether it's corporates, wealthy individuals, what have you, sorta out of necessity, started consuming the product and started realizing that there's some real utility to this. 11:49 Um, and I think that just, again, we just had a step change in like the size of the market and the acceptance, both from a customer and investment standpoint. So now we're actually in like quite a good place. 12:03 A lot of the activity on the certain sectors of the market have picked up and then others have kinda cooled off, particularly like the charter management, and we can talk about that.A little bit, but I would say we're in like a fairly stable investable, um, environment. 12:16 There's been a lot of, a lot of deal activity, capital raising, control M&A, um, you know, and such, and some really, really big assets kind of, you know, trading hands or taking in investments. It's good. 12:27 And it feels like it's more, at least from, from my view, more infrastructure, you know, the, the MRO, the FBO with physical- Yeah... space producing things versus, you know, the charter frenzy that was, was happening. 12:40 Yeah, as a general matter. And that, and that's always the case. Like, if you parallel that to like the aeros- like the commercial aerospace, it's, it's the same thing, right? 12:47 Because you have a huge universe that for years and years before any of this BizAv stuff was on the map, manufacturers of components and aero structures and avionics and electronics, right, like feeding Boeing and Airbus in that example, the MRO space, uh, you know, fueling, ground handling, airport, just kind of the whole... 13:05 That, that has a much wider TAM of investors that sort of are used to and comfortable with that, whether it's private equity debt or public markets. 13:13 But the airline space, if you wanna make the analogy, the people that actually operate the aircraft and have pilots and operations and unions and all this type of stuff, like, that's actually a thinner group of people that, especially in the private equity world, that kind of play in that space. 13:27 So, like, you're always gonna see a disproportionate ratio to the, to the supply side. 'Cause to some extent, you don't have to pick the winner so mu- right? 13:35 Like, especially in the infrastructure, like if the FBO, like if you control the FBO at, you know, name your key airport, like whether it's NetJets, Flexjet, individual Part 91 operate, you know, you kinda, you kinda win either way, which is why investors, um, investors love that space. 13:49 But no doubt, particularly from a private equity side, the MRO supply chain, um, FBO, you know, related even like some softwares and services and other things have, you know, ha- have really become like very popular investments. 14:04 And the good news is, is like it's just viewed as a sector that is an industrial sector that has above average growth- Mm-hmm... trends to it. And another thing that people often forget, it's a very US story. 14:18 So sometimes when there's like screwy geopolitical situations or a little bit unsure environments or, you know, cur- currency things, like the BizAv sector is a lot more US-based than commercial aerospace. 14:31 You have a lot less dynamics about, well, how's China gonna react to, you know, Boeing if they have tensions with the US, for example, right? Like in our case, we don't have that as much here. 14:42 So in some cases, when that dynamic is going on in the world, BizAv also looks, you know, better as long as people believe in kind of North America. And, and less concentration. 14:51 I mean, you know, we're, you know, there's more competitive ability than these large airlines, and everything's down to Boeing or an Airbus. Like we've got more OEMs, we've got more competitors. Yes. Yes, exactly right. 15:02 And then, and then the biggest fundamental, um, shift that we have going on that benefits, I think, the charter, you, you guys tell me too, but like the charter operator managers and to some extent the, you know, the MROs and the FBO is not only is the just overall pie growing around biz av-- business aviation, but also the, there's a shift going on of whole aircraft ownership to sort of other ways to consume the product into like these big companies that frankly have found a more efficient way to utilize assets and still provide a great service. 15:36 So like, you know, you kind of have growth within growth a little bit to the extent that you're in the business of either servicing or operating as a, you know, as a fractional or a big branded charter or a manager. 15:49 You know, the, the-- that's been one of the biggest changes, right, is just there's a lot of other ways than like owning your own whole aircraft and your own flight department and all that type of stuff. 15:57 And that, you know, there are puts and takes of who wins and loses in those dynamics, but, um, I think that's been something that is sort of well understood in Wall Street and people are big believers in. 16:07 Yeah, I think that makes sense. I mean, you look at, you look at fractional, and it's the only thing that's growing, uh, you know, year over year post-COVID. It's the only one that's on a significant growth trajectory. 16:17 You know, Part 91 traditional charter or traditional flight department is on a, is on a net decline, as is branded charter, just kind of at a macro level. 16:26 And I, I think that your point about, you know, picks and shovel businesses, right? So like the MROs, the FBOs is like you don't have to pick- Yeah... 16:33 you know, the next winner of fractional or the next winner of charter. It's like you kind of win regardless, as long as that macro trend just keeps going up. Yeah, and, and, and you're regulated, right? 16:43 Like, like what's-- Like, you know, we, we were lucky enough to represent, uh, you know, West Star Aviation, right, in their, in their latest transaction, um, and, and, uh, sale to the Greenbrier Equity Group. 16:55 Like, one of the things that investors loved about that business, one, big large scale independent, right? So they're not tied specifically to any, um, you know, just Gulfstream or just Embraer. 17:06 I mean, obviously they have their concentration, but it's a very diversified from that standpoint. But also too, it's regulated, right? So back to your point of like, listen, a lot of this stuff is calendar-driven. 17:15 You don't have a choice, right? It's either time-driven, calendar-driven, but like frankly, a lot of it is cal- calendar-driven in their business. 17:21 Those are the type of things, and it's why private equity and debt particularly loves aerospace and defense broadly, is they just have-- there's a perceived kind of higher bar barrier from a competitive standpoint and a predictability to it. 17:36 It's why you see, you know, StandardAero, right? That's one of the names that touches our sector in a big way, um, that has gone public in the last couple years. 17:43 Like, you know, those engines are on s- cycle-driven maintenance programs. Like you can't, you know, as long as those aircraft are flying, they're gonna be maintained, right? 17:52 And the costs keep escalating and going up and inflation and such like that. So I think, you know, if you take an FBO analogy, it's the fact that you kind of have your barriers and long-term leases on the airport. 18:02 That's like their X factor and why that sector has become so popular, particularly with infrastructure funds. 18:08 And then the MROs within largely the private equity community, but some in the public equity community, um, just that regulated, you know, kind of nature to it and not, again-Most commercial MROs that we deal with, a lot of them have big exposure because to, to certain customers, 'cause there's only a handful of airlines in the world, you know, there's such scale. 18:27 You don't have that in the biz of world in the, in the same way, right? So, like private equity investors don't like to see 40% of your revenue coming from one customer that could pull a contract at any time. 18:39 It is time for us to talk about our sponsor this season on the VIPC podcast, AB Jets. We are currently on their Challenger 3500, which is owned and operated, so not managed. They don't have any managed fleet. 18:50 It's all owned by the company, which means they're gonna say yes when you book their, when you book their flights. Yeah. And I think a lot of people... 18:57 You know, I was- I found a Grand View Aviation, we did the same thing. We owned and operated our fleet, and they were like, "What? Are you crazy?" 19:02 I'm like, "I wanna deliver good customer service and the best quality product that I can." And the only way you can do that is if you have full control of the aircraft. They specced out the whole interior. 19:11 There's no weird, "Oh, my owner likes this weird, like gold thing in the bathroom." Like, it's made for charter clients. It's beautiful. It has all the specs that you need. 19:20 But also having control of availability, having control of what's in service and what's not, like that is so huge for brokers. Yeah, exactly. And when it's owned and operated, you know... 19:30 Uh, they also staff their team 24/7. So not only is it an owned and operated, but somebody answers the phone when you call. Yeah. So, you kind of have two sides of an awesome operator for brokers. 19:41 I have some broker friends who asked me to give employees at AB Jets hugs- [chuckles]... when they found out that I was gonna be here- Yeah... 'cause they love them so much. 19:49 So, owned and operated fleet, brand-new Challenger 3500, which is crazy. The only owned and operated supplemental lift or 135 charter only aircraft available on the market. 20:00 So thanks, AB Jet, for your sponsorship and your partnership this season of the VIPC podcast. 20:05 So something I'm curious about, because this happened, you know, when we did our exit, uh, you know, one of the things that's happening is the aircraft values are trending so much higher than they used to. 20:13 You know, the value just continues to climb. Yeah. And even when we sold, you know, even after putting thousands of hours on assets, the assets were worth more than when we purchased them. So I mean, do charter- Nice... 20:22 operators still have that [chuckles] like in their, in their belt? Because it seems like values just continue to go higher and higher. Yeah. No, no, I, I think, I think it is, it gives... So for, so for like a, um... 20:35 So take the debt side of the equation, which for most operators is usually almost like 60 to 70% of your total capitalization, if you will, just like the, the, the way these things kind of work out. 20:47 Strong or growing asset value, one, give you, um, really good kind of access to capital against your assets. 20:57 So usually what most people do, right, and Preston, like you, you live in this world, like you're gonna first borrow against what can be your most affordable, efficient, you know, cost to capital, which is usually secured, secured asset lending, right? 21:09 Just like any of us would borrow against our home, right? As collateral, you get a, a better rate than like an unsecured loan, right? 21:16 And then second, on top of that, you know, you'll see people tap unsecured markets or just kind of general corporate debt. Even that, while not tied to the assets, it kind of is, right? 21:25 Because they're looking at, hey, okay, if the secured lenders have got 21:29 65% LTV and I feel good about these values, and I'm next in line, even though I'm not kind of directly secured by that, I, I kind of have that there as a, as the residual value. 21:40 So really, and, and same with an equity investor. They'll say, "Okay, listen, I'm thinking about paying X for this company based on multiple of EBITDA, return on cash flow," kind of all the different valuation metrics. 21:51 But then they're also kind of cross-referencing saying, "Hey, listen, there's a bunch of kind of embedded value in this fleet alone." 21:57 And it just, it's just another thing to like triangulate around and, and help, you know, and help feel comfortable with. 22:03 Now, the other side of that is those that kind of live in an asset-light model, whether it's a management company or, um, y- you know, a business that kind of 22:13 leases their aircraft or has some sort of tie-up with underlying owners. 22:17 Like, that doesn't mean those companies are uninvestable by any means, 'cause obviously the other side of that coin is, like they don't have to put the cash flow out in the same way or take that risk and all the debt, you know, to do it, and they kind of operate on an asset-light, um, mode. 22:33 Either of, either of those can work from an investment standpoint. It just depends. Honestly, at the end of the day, it comes down to the, the management team, the relative position of those businesses. 22:42 Like there's a place, there's a place for all of that. Um, but- Does the as- do the asset-light providers have to be larger scale to attract institutional investor? 22:50 Like y- like I think about, you know, the, the companies that have largely managed fleets and, you know, wanting to raise institutional capital versus I have my own fleet, right? 23:01 So we, we, we've talked a couple times about Jesse's exit, right? In today's world, as a number of aircraft would not be necessarily considered a scale player if it was all managed and leased, right? 23:10 It's, it would be a very small company. Like how do you think about scale when it comes to these asset-light companies as opposed to I own and operate my own fleet? Like what, like- Yeah... how does scale play into that? 23:22 I, I honestly, I, I think, so from, from, from my seat, we're typically-- Like our, our typical M&A deal, like if you just look at Jefferies, right? 23:31 Our average M&A deal is probably 6 or $700 million of enter- of enterprise value. 23:36 But that is wildly skewed because, you know, as I always say to people, I only, we, we, our practice in, in New York for Jefferies is really only focused on commercial aerospace and business aviation. 23:48 So like we're very narrow in what we do, w- meaning I have a whole 'nother set of partners, you know, who do defense and government and space. 23:54 So it's a diff- another difference about Jefferies is there's multiple, you know, mes. I run the group, but there's multiple mes that are focused in other areas. 24:02 So we are like in one little area, so therefore we're doing deals and transactions all up and down the size range, and we're-- that we just prefer to be deep versus wide. 24:11 And I think it works out well because oftentimes the people buying or investing at the bigger end are also our clients, and it, it just sort of helps connect the dots. 24:19 But I would say scale for, for what we see in, in businesses that we work with, almost regardless of asset light or heavy, there, there is a certain like premium to scale, especially if you're trying to attract like traditionalPrivate equity. 24:34 Public markets is a whole different thing. We can talk about that. 24:37 That requires, uh, public debt and public equity require an increasingly large scale unless you're doing something like a SPAC deal or, or something like that. 24:46 But like a traditional IPO, you know, you need to be in the hundreds of millions of EBITDA and up in enterprises value kind of up into the billions to, to really kinda make it work. 24:57 But in the private equity world, I think regardless of business model, if you are-- You know, how you define scale, you know, probably you can start like over ten million of EBITDA, plus like there starts to be a pretty wide, uh, especially if you're in one of those, uh, what did you call it? 25:13 The sh-shovel business, like the, the industrial, like if you're in more of the MRO- Yeah, like picks and shovels, like MRO- Yeah... FBO software- Yeah... or something like that. 25:22 You know, there you could have, you know, five million, four million, three million, two million. 25:25 But I think for the charter operators, because of what we said earlier, there has been this sort of like flight to quality and flight to scale theme going on in our industry, and that's, I think, seen on Wall Street where people are gonna be a little more careful about, like really taking investment in a smaller player unless they have a very defined niche or a very sig- you know, specific purpose for which they're taking on investment, whether it's to facilitate a, you know, a merger or to go on an M&A kind of spree or, or, or what have you. 25:57 So- Yeah. 25:57 Well, and I think the, as the, as the world of the SPAC and excitement about taking over America, you know, or, or whatever it is, I mean, I feel like that's, that's not as exciting, or at least at the moment not as enticing to investors than it was, you know, five years ago. 26:12 Yeah. There's a pretty, um, for like emerging business models, disrupted business model, I'm speaking purely within aviation, there's kind of like a, there's a pretty big risk off on that in general. 26:23 And part of it is just like there's so many companies trying to go public. The M&A markets are so hot at, at the moment. 26:29 The last couple weeks have been a little, obviously a little, um, disjointed, but frankly, everything is kinda still for the most part pushing forward. 26:36 But, um, I, I would say there are so many opportunities out there for full-on acquisitions, for new IPOs coming to market for debt issuances. 26:48 It's-- A-and remember, we're in a slightly higher interest rate environment than we were during that SPAC craze where you couldn't-- there was no risk-free return anywhere else, so people kinda leaned out on the, you know, the, the risk curve. 26:59 Like that's not the case anymore. 27:01 And so I think for our world, if you look at most investors, they're gonna much prefer backing, even if it means at a, you know, higher premium, higher multiple, whatever, backing the sort of bigger, more established players and brands, and that applies to charter, that applies to maintenance, it applies to, you know, FBOs as well. 27:19 So do you think-- If you think like z- like on that point, is there an opportunity for like a lower level roll-up? Like could you go SPAC together 15 small charter operators and kind of rebrand? 27:32 Or would you say that it's more the larger operators, like capital's gonna gravitate more towards, you know, call it the Wheels Up, the Vistas who can opportunistically pick off the people that it makes sense, but they don't have to. 27:45 They could just grow organically. I think it depends, and I, I'd be curious to hear your guys' take on this too. So one thing that I observed, and it goes back to what we were talking about earlier. 27:54 So I think for the people saying, "Hey, we wanna be the big 28:00 brands and sort of retail," meaning direct to consumer, business owner, whomever, I think there's a pretty strong belief now that you've got, you know, obviously you've got NetJets, and if this is from a US perspective, largely you've got NetJets, you've got the Flex family of brands, right? 28:17 Which have, you know, grown rapidly over the last, um, decade. You've got Vista that has done the same. 28:23 You've got Wheels Up that has become-- even though they've sorta, they're in a mode of get smaller first to get bigger, but that's because they're transforming their entire business model and the, the level of, um, accomplishment they've had since the whole management changeover and the Delta investment is actually, you know, is quite impressive, right? 28:41 They've re-fleeted everything, rebranded, et cetera. 28:43 Um, you know, you've got your kinda handful of, of, of players, and then you have, you know, the very long-established sort of, uh, players like your PlaneSenses of the world that have been out there for a long time, and they're end of the market. 28:56 Like I think if you came and said, "Hey, we wanna become the new retail player," and I don't know if that's a perfectly right word for what I'm calling these guys, the branded operators, you're probably gonna get some skepticism, especially as you pointed out earlier. 29:08 There's just been such a flock to, you know, kind of the big, well-capitalized, kinda larger aircraft, uh, fractional players. But what I find interesting, and Jess, you would be uniquely, um, 29:20 qualified to speak to this, is one thing that happened though is any of those players, right? 29:25 Still rely from time to time or, or more significantly on, you know, your kinda more private label, B2B sub-charter, you know, whatever the- Mm-hmm... correct term people like to use. 29:36 And that space got really hollowed out for a period of time, yourself included, where they actually, you know, the players that ex-- I mean, I think we did five of those on the buy side for Wheels Up alone during that time, and obviously Flex- Yeah... 29:48 did a couple, and Vista did three or four. Where a lot of those like, you know, B2B white label people kinda went away because they got consumed into the whatever customer was in, in most need of it. Yeah. 30:01 So actually, that space has become quite, um, open in a lot of ways. By, by, by my eye, by the Wall Street eye- Mm-hmm... you don't have that like big player. O- Yeah, no, I think- Yeah... 30:13 I think the world is waiting for more of those like, you know, 10 to 20 airplane operators, and they're rebuilding. You know, there are a couple out there that are on their way. Yep. 30:20 But, but like you said, I think it's at this point tho-those are kind of the, the organic growers, the ones who make the right choices, who control cost, have good margins. 30:30 That's the one, you know, eventually who's gonna get, you know, rolled up in a, in a good way for everybody and not just like a-Yeah, exactly. 30:37 And so, and so what my, so what my investors, like if we had a really promising CEO, founder, uh, entrepreneur who had one of these companies and, you know, maybe had its fleet and was building and was doing really good, you know, kind of flying for whoever, for your NetJets or your Flexes of the world, um, and making a nice kind of, you know, nice business kind of at a B2B way- Mm-hmm... 30:59 and they wanted to take on an investor to go consolidate more of the space, I mean, that's where it really gets down to the quality of the team in the thesis because any one of my, you know, private equity clients or, or asset managers would say, "Okay, this sounds interesting. 31:14 You management team, tell me what is the benefit of rolling all this up, and how do you handle the certificate complexity and the fleet commonality, and, you know, what does it do?" 31:23 And like if there's a good answer to that and a demonstrated path, like that becomes very, that becomes very investable, right? You know, does that all make, does that all make sense? 31:33 Like those things are not easy to do. And that's, that's the hard part is, is- That's the hard part... 31:35 yeah, to is, you know, when you have a nice clean, you know, consistent fleet that's running with one certificate, it's running like a well-oiled machine, it's great, you know? 31:44 And then when you try to consolidate and push them together, that's where a lot of the hard part comes in. Well, right. 31:49 And, and public investors, and a lot of people have seen this very publicly with the airlines, right? Every time the airlines try to merge, you know, you get certificates- Mm-hmm... 31:56 and unions and this and that and fleet commonality issues and, you know, I mean, that was the hard part that, um, Wheels Up had to manage when they were doing their, you know, kind of hyper acquisition. 32:05 They would have assets sitting there ready to go, but pilots from a different certificate sitting there, and they couldn't get in the... You know, like that type of stuff like takes time- Mm-hmm... to work through. 32:14 Um, but I, I actually find that part of the market maybe potentially interesting for, you know, new investment or private equity entrants to kind of, you know, create a really big mid-size, um, 32:28 you know, B2, B2B provider if you, if you will. 32:31 I think there's an interesting s- trend in that comment in that you have a few operators who almost seem to be the, the discards is the wrong word, but I'm trying to come up... 32:42 Like Baker just bought a bunch of old Flexjet Challenger 300s. Yeah. You have- Yep... um, y- y- Bel Air, which is now rebranded, who got a lot of old Vista Citation X's, and you kind of have- Yep, the EXO fleet. Yep. 32:54 Yeah, the EXO fleet. There's a lot of-- There's the, the Wheels Up King Air fleet is now floating around there to a couple of smaller operators. 33:01 So you have almost as the big players are consolidating or changing over their fleet, it's almost like there's this spill down, same aircraft, right? The, the, the airplane itself is moving into a different operator. 33:12 Um, but I, I would not say that, at least to my knowledge, that I know of anybody who's kind of climbing up from the bottom. They're not buying-- Y- there's, or there's few, right? 33:20 There, there's, there might be a couple that are organically stacking new or newer aircraft in order to be able to serve that s- supplemental lift for the large branded operators. Yep. I would add in too, Contour, right? 33:31 Contour did a big deal with, uh, with Wheels Up on some of their old fleet too. 33:35 And, and in some of those deals that I have knowledge of, that also comes back with contracted flying, at least for, for, uh, uh, a, a moment, right? 33:45 So maybe, you know, those groups acquire the, the sort of the excess fleet, um, you know, in an exchange because, you know, dropping all that out of your fleet when your Wheels or Vista or Flex, like there's a period of time or maybe an extended period of time where you're gonna still need and want that lift. 34:00 They're just trying to get their own kind of asset management strategy intact. 34:04 And like that's where you can create a real win-win versus like a Contour or a Bel Air kind of saying, "Hey, I'm gonna like take these aircraft and then go try to be the big retail provider where my name's on all these commercials and this and that." 34:17 Like I think they've found-- I mean, that there's a, there's an ecosystem that exists. 34:20 It works in the commercial airline world, you know, as well, where you, you, you know, you c- you can do that, and you can make, you know, you have less, 34:28 you know, kind of retail risk, and you're kind of, you're able to, you know, t-take, take flights and missions as, you know, at, at a, at a price that kind of earns you a return and also, um, works for it. 34:41 But yeah, I don't think you're gonna see... I think is what you're saying, Preston, like you're not gonna see or we have not seen someone make a big order with Textron to support that model or with, with Gulf, right? 34:50 Yeah, exactly. Exactly. Kind of. Like you, you don't have- Finding that to work... you don't have the, you don't have the B2B charter guys going out. Like, okay, our sponsor, AB Jets, they bought three Challenger 3500s. 35:00 That's three aircraft. That's not 30, right? Right. And so like you're-- It's not like, "Hey, here's our, you know, here's our long-term scale play to be the non-branded operator." 35:10 Like just, you know, I, I know that Grandview had a lot of NetJets contracts, right? They fit the certain criteria that allowed for, for NetJets to go off fleet. 35:19 Whereas I, I don't, a- at least I don't see that in the market. There's not-- I wouldn't say that, yeah, let me point right there. That's the person who provides all the supplemental lift to these operators. Yeah. 35:29 And I think that's the opportunity, and you've kind of named a bunch of the, right, uh, uh, your, like you say, your Bakers, your Contours, you know, because FlyExclusive, right, Jim, he's gone. 35:38 I mean, that's kind of how, at least when I met him, that's what they were doing, and then, you know, they saw a pocket, an opportunity, and sort of, you know, developed their own kind of brand, and now they're off, you know, kind of competing more in that, that bigger space. 35:50 That was a big hole too. So like between acquisitions, changes in strategies, like, um, like FlyExclusive and others, like, you know, it's a, it's an interesting, it's an interesting model. 36:00 So like my investors, you know, I don't think any of that's ready for the public market, so you could put that aside. 36:05 But like from a private equity or growth equity standpoint or structured equity, however you do it, um, 36:12 if it's the right team and strategy and the economics sort of work, like that's a- absolutely backable for, you know, to, to get behind a, you know, to get behind a team. The key question, though, on the operator side 36:25 is what's the end game for a lot of these? And that's been like the big, you know, question as this whole sector plays out. Like, what's the ultimate end game for some of these-Operators Yeah Right? 36:38 Well, and the way that, the way that I, I looked at it, you know, back when we were building was like, let's be the wholesale, you know, white-tailed fleet for these big companies- Yeah... while we build the retail side. 36:49 Because you can't really build the retail if you don't have the scale. You know, your customer doesn't live just in New York or Toronto. 36:53 And it's hard to get scale just starting day one, you know, selling to consumers, right? You- Right. Like, yeah, so you're gonna have to do that wholesale side of it. 37:00 But also, like, I'd just caution those listening, like, it's great to get into these deals, but there's also been cases where you have too many eggs in one basket. 37:08 [laughs] So you just need to make sure you're kind of balancing- Yeah... who all you're whole... And we've seen this with airlines too, you know, American Eagle, whoever. 37:14 Look at the regional, look at the regional airline space. Right, right. 37:17 Like, you know, the SkyWest, I mean, for every SkyWest, which is a, you know, a very flourishing, well-capitalized public company, there are a lot of those that did not end particularly well because they got themselves too tied to United, American, you know, whoever, and then when they shift their strategy or go to a different provider, you're, you're, you're kind of, um, you're kind of in a tough spot. 37:37 Um, but I would say even, even for the big retail guys, right? Like, I mean, obviously NetJets kind of lives... 37:43 You know, if, if this thing, this whole thing would be very different if, if NetJets, you know, who's been big and large and the, the, the name brand forever was a public company, I bet you you'd probably see at least two or three more other public companies. 37:55 Because the way the public markets work, they tend to, like, wanna look at another perfect comp that's kind of already out there in the public space, and then they can make their relative assessments about valuation. 38:06 You know, the tricky thing is for our space is we don't have, other than standard Arrow, and that itself is still largely, you know, it's got a big commercial Arrow story to it, right? 38:15 I mean, they're really into, like, large engines now in addition to what they do in our world. Um, but you don't have, you don't have really many comps, even the FBO space, right? 38:24 So what's interesting now is you have very large institutional capital involved in Flex, involved in Vista, obviously you have public money and then, uh, uh, you know, strategic investment in Wheels Up via, via Delta. 38:37 And then the two huge FBO chains, you know, have giant name brand institutional investor, investors behind them, great assets, great trajectory. 38:47 I mean, these are, these are, all of these companies are, you know, approaching $10 billion and over, right? I mean, these are huge companies. 38:54 Um, but none of them have gone public yet, at least as a pure play, 'cause even Signature lived inside of BBA, which was sort of this odd conglomerate over in the UK listing. 39:05 Um, and then Atlantic was owned by Macquarie Infrastructure. That had power plants and natural gas. I mean, it was all sort... There's never been, like, a pure play- Hmm... asset. 39:15 And so that's gonna be the interesting thing, 'cause when these companies get to this size, you know, you're either kind of constantly taking on growth or minority investors, or eventually you're gonna go public and, and that'll be, that'll be really interesting because then it'll finally set like a real public valuation on, on certain of these sectors, right? 39:31 We know very clearly what the private, you know, what the private markets, um, look at, but the public markets have, have yet to be tested. That's a great transition. So we'll see, we'll see who gets there first. 39:41 [laughs] Well, I just wanted to bring up, uh, we wanna have a conversation about EBITDA. [laughs] I was about to say the exact same thing. Yeah. [laughs] And EBITDAR. Nick- And EBITDAR... 39:49 I need you to explain EBITDAR and why it's a metric anybody cares about, because I've yet to have anybody really explain it to me why- It, it do- Listen, all, all it really is at the end of the day is people trying to normalize between different 40:06 model, business models of ownership, right? Because if you're an asset-heavy company, let's say you're a charter company and you own the vast majority of your assets, okay? 40:16 Earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization doesn't capture either the depreciation that comes from the assets, which of course is a financial non-cash metric. 40:27 It also doesn't capture the interest cost associated with likely financing such a large fleet, and of course it doesn't capture at least the equity portion of the CapEx required to, you know, maintain and/or grow that fleet. 40:42 So if you own, you know, $4 or 5, $6 billion of aircraft assets and you're looking at EBITDA, you're not getting, you know, you're not getting the full picture. 40:50 On the other hand, if you're a very large operator that uses operating leases, you know, that's flowing through your income statement as rent and therefore is. 40:59 And so, like, if you're trying to compare those two models, you're gonna get to kinda apples and oranges. So, like, I don't think... I, I view this as 41:08 a- any investor or ourselves when we're assessing a situation, we very quickly normalize for that. And so EBITDAR, just like EBITDA, is a shorthand kinda way to look at operational cash flow. 41:19 It's not perfect, but it, it kinda works for most situations. EBITDAR is kinda meant to be a way to, like, a- adjust, adjust for that to, to some extent. 41:28 But at the end of the day, investors are really looking down to, like, what's the ultimate, you know, cash flow generation? What are the return on the assets? 41:35 So, you know, to me, when I look at someone that is asset heavy, I'm looking below and I'm saying... 41:42 D- 'cause depreciation's just a fixed, you know, that, that's, that's kind of an accounting thing, so really what you're looking at is, okay, how much below the line, as we call it in our industry in EBITDA, needs to go back in to maintain? 41:53 'Cause sometimes another tricky thing that you didn't ask about but now I'll tell you about- [laughs]... is some operators have different accounting policies for maintenance, right? Mm-hmm. 42:02 And, and so, like, sometimes- Engine programs... 42:04 flowing through the income statement, sometimes they're actually capitalizing engine overhauls or cabin restorations or other things, and you wouldn't see that up here, it's down here. 42:13 And so what we usually look at is we'll say, okay, take EBITDA as a starting point, but then if you've got a really big kinda asset intensity, what amount of capital needs to go into just maintaining the fleet, meaning your capitalized maintenance expenses? 42:26 Then there's sort of the re- replacement angle of it. Then there's sort of, well, then what do you need for growth? And that sort of, kind of steps in for the, for the DA part, right? 'Cause DA is accounting. 42:37 I wanna look at actually, you know, what kind of cash is, is going in there. And then that's gonna be able to give you a better apples to apples view of someone who's just having, you know, kinda o- operating leases. 42:48 So, like, 42:49 we, we, we preach, like, when we prep, either when we're assessing a situation to see if and how we could help-Or even when we're out in front of investors, we're very big on sort of transparency and giving people access to the information they need to kinda come at it their own way. 43:04 'Cause everyone has their own different way of looking at it and, um, things they like to think about. 43:09 So we try to be very-- It never makes any sense when you're running a process, in my opinion, where you sort of put something on a page at a high level that looks really snazzy. 43:17 You get a bunch of people interested and maybe bidding, depending on, like, if you're running an auction situation. You know, they're bidding the book as you speak. 43:24 And then, like, they get to the next round, you make certain decisions about who you wanna spend more time with, and they haven't really seen the details they need. 43:31 And then you just set yourself up for, um, I don't even wanna call it a retrade 'cause that's not fair because they haven't seen the information. 43:38 But we're very, um, information forward, unless there's a competitive, you know, something where you gotta be a little guarded. But let's just say there's no competitive concern. Lay that stuff out there. 43:47 Allow people to kinda have the pieces of the puzzle they need and transparency so that they can do their own analysis. 43:53 'Cause e- like listen, I always say, like, to clients, like, we may not like the answer, but I'd rather know the actual answer rather than, you know, someone kinda putting a number out there that's just gonna disappoint us later. 44:03 'Cause you could then very easily leave someone else behind who maybe actually had a more constructive view, and you were just kinda making decisions. 44:10 So we, we try to front-load access to the different kinda levels around that. Um, you know, so again, EBITDA has really just meant-- None of this is, none of these are GAAP figures, EBITA, EBITDAR, right? Mm-hmm. 44:21 These, these are all kinda investment world shorthand. 44:24 And then- But it really matters for, I mean, these fleets, you know, 'cause if people, if investors don't understand where those assets are on the depreciation curve, I mean, [chuckles] you know, or the expense costs, like, you really need to be educated on that if you're looking at these firms. 44:38 E- exactly right, and that's why kinda laying out very clearly, like, what you're spending below the line to just maintain them, right? 44:44 'Cause there, there's a, there's a trade-off between asset acquisition costs and operational costs, right? 44:49 And there's somewhere on the curve that is optimal and, and frankly, that may be different for different business models. Like- Mm-hmm... 44:56 you know, acquiring five to ten-year-old, old fleet, like those could still be put into fraction. You know, if it's got like I'm a big, you know-- I worked at Delta, I'm a big Delta fan as a, as a, as a customer. Like, 45:07 I know as sort of an industry person, I'll walk on, and I know that plane's twenty-five years old, but, like, the cabin looks good, the Wi-Fi works, people have a smile, and they leave, you know. Mm-hmm. 45:16 The flights leave on time, I'm, I'm good, right? Yeah. I'd rather that than a brand-new plane that, you know, looks terrible and doesn't work. 45:22 So, like, you can, you can buy down the curve and kinda have a, you know, better return than, um, than otherwise. 45:28 But I, I just think you really gotta kinda lay it out, uh, very clearly and, and give people the tools they need to make their own decisions. You really can't force valuation down people. 45:38 You know, there's kinda set comps, and every deal has it. And that's why w- we, you know, we sit in a fortunate position with clients or buyers is like we've often worked on the past transactions. 45:47 So some people will say to us, like, "Well, why did that trade for fourteen times when I'm at here or this?" 45:52 And I was like, "Well, you know, either, like, the forward numbers look like this, or you didn't see the CapEx, or there was a big contract." 45:58 You know, there's always-- These aren't like publicly traded stock prices where the price is the price and it's very transparent. There's a lot of stuff that goes into these. 46:06 And- You know, even the- And sometimes it's h-how motivated is someone to close [chuckles] sometimes, you know? Like that's- Well, yeah... yeah. No, e- ex- ex- exactly right. 46:14 Um, and, and so there's a story behind every, you know, multiples as advertised is really just a, you know, uh, is just an output of the analysis that pe- It's just a common way for people to say, what was the price? 46:25 What was the earnings at the time? That was the multiple. But that's not how people are getting to their valuations. They're thinking through, how much do I need to put into this fleet? 46:32 How complicated would integration be? What are the commercial synergy? 46:36 Like, all that stuff is going into their calculus, and it just ends up expressed as a, as a multiple, which just becomes an easy way for all of us to talk about, to talk about deals. 46:45 And things with assets are more complicated. 46:48 The other thing that's made it a little easier now is, you know, with all the accounting changes, lease, lease obligations are more now like on the balance sheet, and there's, there's a proxy for them as debt, right? 46:58 'Cause that's the other unfair thing. 47:00 Like if, you know, you don't have all this liability before on your balance sheet, you know, now there's a way to kinda reflect that, which makes the EBITDA, EBITDA thing a little less, a little less relevant. 47:10 But- Interesting... hopefully that helps. How, how about cumulative losses, Nick? 47:13 There's a, y- y- the, a lot of the public market comps that are out there, and I'm not gonna name specifics 'cause we don't want, wanna get you in compliance trouble. Uh, but a lot of... 47:25 I- it feels like every earnings report that I read has a cumulative loss that feels challenging to overcome, right? So it's like- Yeah... 47:34 you're gonna have to be in operation for a long time or get a lot more customers to overcome your cu-cumulative loss. 47:39 How does, uh, how does cumulative loss play into, you know, that's probably more of a public market, but I would imagine that there's cumulative losses in the private market too. 47:48 Like, how, how should, how should we as, you know, industry people be thinking of cumulative loss? Yeah. 47:54 I-- So yes, and then there's sort of financial losses, and then there's tax losses, where actually in some cases, cumulative losses are seen as an asset, right? 48:02 'Cause you've, you've, you've got a model that, you know, there's a significant tax benefit to those who own assets for the most part, and obviously this latest tax change, um, kind of, uh, further magnified that or at least, you know, rendered them permanent, uh, for the time being anyway. 48:18 So, um, to be perfectly candid, they probably don't get the level of attention you might think. Investors are typically very focused on the forward of the business and like what-- E- even, even debt investors, right? 48:31 They're gonna look at effectively EBITDA, EBITDA, less CapEx, less working capital to really f- Debt investors basically just wanna know, are we gonna be able to get paid back? 48:39 'Cause they generally have no upside in the business. All they wanna do is make sure they get paid back, right? 48:44 So they're gonna look at the actual earnings, forget like the depreciation factors and other things that create, you know, kind of accounting or book losses. They're looking one way. 48:53 And then other investorsThey're kind of looking at, okay, where are we today and where is this going, you know, from an earnings, from an EBITDA, from a competitive positioning growth. 49:02 You know, maybe you'll kind of look into it to the extent that there are tax attributes that could affect value for a deal, positive or negative. 49:09 I've seen that where certain NOLs and other kind of tax-driven losses actually have a discrete value to themselves, um, you know, that kind of get negotiated as part of the valuation consideration. 49:20 But probably not as much as y- as you would, you would think on the, on the balance sheet side, um, at least for private equity investors and to some extent public investors. Interesting. I learned something new today. 49:31 Yeah. [laughs] 'Cause I would have-- I w- In my kind of finite mind, I'm like, well, I have this big... You know, I have not made money for this long, and it's accumulated this much. I have to get above zero 49:41 to, like, be ma- you know, making money, if you will. Yeah. I mean, it's, uh, it's... Yeah. It's all in the past. Yeah. 49:47 [laughs] You're, you're probably going a step further than, uh, most, most do, which, uh, you know, maybe, maybe we all should. 49:52 Um, yeah, it do- it doesn't get the, it doesn't get the level of, uh, attention you, you, you might think. 49:58 Uh, 'cause you go look at that statement of shareholder equity or whatever you have, uh, you see these big kind of negative numbers, but I, I think a lot of that's viewed as accounting, you know, accounting loss, if you will. 50:09 Interesting. The other sticky topic that I wanna get to before we, you know, run out of time, there's like so many things we wanna ask, um, but EVTOLs. You know, how are investors- Yeah... 50:18 looking at that space right now? What's going on lately? Yeah. So I think the EVTOL space, um, during kind of the, you know, 50:28 C-C-COVID through kind of boom '21, '22 days, we saw a lot of them get, get public either directly or, uh, via SPAC deals. 50:36 But, you know, we worked on a couple of them, including the, the Eve transaction, um, which was the spin-out of Embraer. A lot of them are out there. You know, they have a public value kind of stated on there. 50:47 Frankly, none of them really have revenue, right? 50:50 So every quarterly update is basically just product on-- It's basically progress on certification and then cash burn and liquidity, and then like other commercial agreements and such. 51:00 Like there's not, you know, there's not much there. 51:04 Um, you know, today's world you can ac- So if you're, if you're a public EVTOL operator, for some, you can oper- you know, you can still access the public markets, um, whether it's with a traditional follow-on offering or, um, there's a product that's become quite popular called the ATM, which is the at the market, which is effectively, 51:24 uh, I'd almost call it like an equity revolver, where you can kind of dribble in every, you know, day of trading. You can kind of raise capital kind of in a- You can go, you can go to the ATM, if you will. 51:37 If you need more- You can go to the ATM... the ATM, you put your PIN in. Yeah. [laughs] That's not lost on me. Exactly. 51:42 And the higher your, the higher your share trade, the higher your share volume traded, the more you can raise. It's kind of looked at as like a percentage of how much is out there, how much you can kind of dribble in. 51:52 So it's, it's, it's become like actually a fairly, not just for EVTOLs or, or more emerging companies, it's become a really big product in, in just sort of Wall Street generally. 52:02 It's a really, uh, can be really efficient for public companies. Um, 52:07 private investment into that space, whether it's pipes into the, you know, which is a, um, a private investment into a public company, um, or, or other capital raising is a little bit difficult right now. 52:18 Like everyone knows where the sector is going, and I do expect it to be a huge part of, you know, society, right? 52:24 I mean, there's some real very clear use cases and some interesting things that could change a, a lot for the aviation industry. But then you're just getting into picking, picking the winners. Back to- Yeah, when... 52:34 one of you said it earlier about the charter, like it's not exactly where a lot of investors wanna be because it's really difficult to tell. You're gonna have to see some consolidation. 52:43 You've seen a couple of them kind of go away or sell their IP or assets or, you know, um. 52:49 But it's like from a private equity standpoint, like where the vast majority of like MRO and distribution and, you know, more, uh, uh, pick and shovel. Is that what we're calling it? Pick and shovel guys. 53:00 Yeah, pick and shovel. Picks and shovels. Th-that world is not really open to the, for, for the EVTOLs. It's just, it's too speculative. 53:07 And like, again, right now, you got interest rates higher than where they were, and you've just got a lot of other investable opportunities. So like people would much rather invest in the IPO of StandardAero, right? 53:18 A real company with significant earnings growth and market presence than kind of picking a winner, you know, uh, on, on one of these names. 53:26 So a lot of the investment we've seen in that space have either been further follow-on investment from the existing investors or sometimes like a strategic that has a angle into that c- you know, like, "Hey, I'm gonna be the engine manufacturer for this type, and I'm gonna make an investment alongside it." 53:41 Um, but it's- Mm... it's pretty limited other than that. So regardless of business model and what people are working on, you know, I think a lot of people that listen to the show are entrepreneurs. 53:50 What do they need to be doing, you know, they're probably not thinking of, [chuckles] you know, 'cause they're busy running the operation? You know, as an, as someone who sees a lot of deals- Yeah... 53:58 all the time, like what, what are the spaces they need to pay attention to? So, so this, this sector in particular has a very high percentage of real, you know, material players in the space 54:11 that are still founder-led or entrepreneur-led, and in many cases, in a very kinda public way, meaning like they're kind of the faces of their company, right? 54:18 Like we see this way more in this than you would ever see in the defense supply chain or even commercial aerospace. A lot of these companies are just older, bigger, public. 54:28 You know, they just don't-- They've been through multiple kinda iterations. We have a very heavy founder content here, and I would say even more so in the charter fractional management type of space. 54:38 So one of the, one of the things there is like the most you can do to separate-- If you're gonna look to actually sell or sell control or take on a very significant, meaningful kind of equity investor, you're gonna wanna pretty quickly show that the dependency on that one person is not gonna make or break the outcome. 54:59 Because no matter what, even if someoneBought 80% or 90% of your company and you rolled in, yes, they own it and control it economically and at the board level, but they can't run the company. 55:09 They're still backing management. So one of the really important things is like that depth of the team or a very clear transition path or just showing, "Hey, listen. 55:19 Yes, I'm leading the strategic direction, but the company kind of runs itself. I'm not the one that knows personally every single customer and supplier to where if I walked away, you know, that would be at risk." 55:30 That's the biggest risk when you have a founder-led business. And then the other thing is just extracting them from the business eventually. 55:39 That, that's like the, the interesting thing that makes-- I think it's really why you haven't seen some very IPO-able companies not actually go public or saleable companies that have not sold in a full change in control way, like, like a Westar or deals like that, and why maybe you also haven't seen certain strategic combinations that could make a ton of sense for the industry and for everyone because you've got founders who just their lives, you know, it becomes completely interchangeable, right? 56:07 Their lives, their business, it's all intertwined. They love it. Like, clearly a lot of these people don't need money anymore, but they, they just do it 'cause that's what they do and that's what they know. 56:16 So, like, when you're ready, you gotta make sure you've had time to, um, work through that or at least have a plan to work through that so the investors know, you know, especially as you start kinda aging on up. 56:27 The other thing I would say is, um, I would highly recommend engaging earlier than sort of, "I'm ready to run a process, and now I'm gonna go kinda interview a bunch of investment banks." Like, 56:37 in many cases, we work for com-with companies for, you know, for free, right? 56:41 We only get paid when deals happen, but we spend a lot of time thinking through, working with, reviewing information, giving advice about, "Hey, you should think about positioning this," or, "Hey, this is, this financial thing is gonna be a real issue. 56:53 You're gonna wanna w-" Like, that type of stuff because if you've decided this is your moment to sell, that's just gonna elongate the kinda prep process or just put risk to the deal if you don't kinda have people involved earlier, at least in an informal, informal way. 57:07 Um, uh, and then obviously cleaning up, you know, a lot of people, if you're running a business for yourself, like your, your financials can have a lot of things in it that are optimizing for your personal situation, and that's fine. 57:18 That's totally understood and accepted, but, like, getting ahead of all that, um, too. But the biggest thing is the bench and the continuity. 57:25 You do not wanna be seen-- I know it's counterintuitive to a lot of people that are, like, hard-charging entrepreneurs. They wanna be seen as the one that, you know, "I'm the one who makes everything happen." 57:34 But that's actually a negative when you're thinking about doing something like this. All right, Nick. 57:38 Uh, one last question that I get a lot from people in the industry, kinda, you know, cocktail conversations is Bond getting a huge raise from KKR. 57:49 Is there room for another scale fractional player that's maybe premium luxury? Like, how, how do you view, uh, how much more room there is kind of in the fractional space for multiple brands? Yeah. 58:01 Well, I mean, so, so, uh, I know, I know Sergei and Bill very well. I've worked with each of them in the past. 58:07 Think, think, think the world of those guys, and they've, they've obviously been very successful in their own right. 58:12 Um, they have picked, uh, you know, an aircraft OEM that has proven to be very popular, um, amongst the fractional and frankly the Part 91, um, space there. 58:23 Um, and there's some proven success to their track records, right? 58:27 Um, um, i-in the past, and I think that, you know, by, uh, we, we did not work on that transaction at all, but I'm very familiar with the situation and know, know the principals very well. Um, 58:37 the track record of prior success with KKR, um, you know, with, with JetEdge, so with Bill, um, you know, when you find success, um, you know, with someone and it's someone you've been in business with before, makes it a heck of a lot easier to go back and kind of, um, do it again. 58:53 So I think that helped them significantly. 58:55 And if you think back to the, what we were talking about earlier, this seems to be where the, you know, I'm a hockey guy, so, like, where the puck is going right now is to more of this fractional. 59:05 It's part the tax benefits, part the service and the model, you know, seems to work well and a- and appeal to investors. 59:12 And if you're hitting the ultimate ultra kinda luxury tip of the spear, as I understand about their kinda plan, it's gonna be, you know, even more discerning and, and bespoke from, like, a branding and service standpoint. 59:23 You know, that's where you have literally the people that fly above the weather, right? 59:27 Um, so, you know, if that service is there and they can execute operationally, um, and customer service, I would say yeah, and I don't think that's a zero-sum game, you know, where the pie then gets smaller for any of the other players. 59:41 Um, you know, I think, I think, uh, a, a different offering in that space, um, I think there's, I think there's plenty of room, and I'm excited to see what those guys can do. Me too. 59:49 I think too, I look at, you know, just the shadow that NetJets cast across the whole industry. If you look at their activity versus every single other operator, it's, it's unbelievably smaller. So I, I'm- It is. 1:00:00 I tend to agree that there, there is room for more and bigger, um, and to keep challenging the traditionals. Yeah. No, I think, yeah, look, it's good for the industry. 1:00:08 It spurs competition and innovation and, um, you know, there's plenty of capital out there as, you know, as, as these guys found with, you know, with basically a sheet of paper, right? 1:00:18 That's happened a few times now where, you know, people who are proven executives in the space have sort of an idea or concept, like the market will be there. And there's a lot of creative ways, 1:00:28 um, you know, to do that and to raise capital. 1:00:30 That-that's one of the best things that came out of COVIDUm, where remember we were talking earlier about the dislocation of, um, no one could find normal for, like, a full sale. 1:00:42 Like, it was like, you know, sellers were thinking here, buyers were thinking here. What kind of created itself out of that was all these different structured, "Well, we could do minority. 1:00:50 We can do structured off your assets. We can do convertibles. We can do pref's. We c- there's so much technology now, and all these big financial instit- like KKR, perfect example. 1:01:00 They're known as a buyout shop historically. Like, they were, like, the original, like, private equity LBO guys. But they're basically a giant asset manager. They have p- I mean, they, they manage insurance money. 1:01:10 They have debt. They have infrastructure. They have regular private equity. 1:01:14 I mean, the, the, the, the availability of sort of capital, you know, you almost-- Like what I always tell, uh, our clients when we're doing something other than, like, just a broad auction or IPO is like, "Let's just start explaining the company and what you're looking to achieve, your objectives, whether that's for the business or you personally or your shareholders, and then let's not go out with, like, a term sheet of this is how we're doing it. 1:01:35 Describe the situation and then let each investor try to solve it in their own way, and if anything..." Because these investors all have their playbooks they go to. 1:01:43 So, like, you know, obviously in that situation, they had run this playbook once before, right? Uh, you know, at least with, with, uh, with Bill's private company. 1:01:52 So then they kind of know what they go back to, and everything kind of works efficiently. 1:01:55 Like, let these, let the investors kind of go to their ways they're used to working or have found success and prop- you know, propose something to you. And the beauty is then we get to sit back. 1:02:05 We have all the cards of how people are basically offering to solve our problem, and we can either pick one or, you know, take the best ideas from other people and try to get it into something versus being overly prescriptive on, like, how you want the capital to come in. 1:02:19 There's just, there's way more creativity out there now, um, which is, uh, just a, it's just a positive for everyone. It's good for the investors, and it's good for the, you know, the clients, your listeners. Sweet. 1:02:30 Well, Nick, we have really appreciated you, uh, being on the podcast. This was a fascinating conversation. 1:02:37 Um, is there anything else that you want to leave our listeners with, just like a little, one little more, if you have one more nugget of wisdom or, like, you know, blow some minds right here before the end of the podcast? 1:02:46 [laughs] No, I, I think I kinda, I think I kinda left it all out on the field. But I, you know, we always, uh, we appreciate it very much, you know, being involved in this. 1:02:54 And Jess, I've known you for a long time, and, um, I, I love what you guys are doing. Our industry needed something like this, um, you know, from a, from a communication, modern-day communication standpoint. 1:03:04 Um, thank you. And, you know, like I said, we, we always welcome meeting, you know, new companies, new executives, or new investors, you know, well ahead of anything actually going on. 1:03:13 Uh, we, we live in a very small world, so look forward to meeting more people and helping where we can. Awesome. Well, thanks, Nick. Uh- Thank you... 1:03:20 to wrap us up, that has been an awesome episode of "The VIP Seat" podcast. If you liked this one, we need you to leave us a five-star review and say how much you loved having Nick on the podcast, that it was awesome. 1:03:33 Leave us comments on YouTube. Share it with everybody you know in business aviation, whether they are, uh, someone who works in management, someone in finance, someone who is in acquisitions. 1:03:43 Uh, this is a playbook for setting up your company for private equity rounds or raising capital or selling your company. Um, this is a great place to do it. Go subscribe to the newsletter at thevipseat.com. 1:03:55 For my awesome co-host, Jesse Naor, and our great guest this week, Nick Fazioli, thank you, AB Jets, for sponsoring this week's episode of the podcast, and we will see you all next week. 1:04:08 [outro music]